Buffalo Nickel Price Guide - Search Shopping

Compare Products

Choose upto 5 items for side by side feature comparison

Wishlist

Go to collections

Show filters

Shop Buffalo Nickel Price Guide

Sponsored

Used

2026 Red Book - Guide Book Of U.…

$17.95

Littleton Coin Co…

Used

Five Cent Piece - Buffalo - 1937 MS…

$109.00

Littleton Coin Co…

Used

Buffalo Nickel Collection With Fo…

$149.00

Littleton Coin Co…

Used

1937-D Buffalo Nickel, 3-Legged …

$2,575.00

Littleton Coin Co…

Mark Klimek Blue Book: Gold Edition

1937 Buffalo Nickel | Gem Uncirculate…

$124.00

Littleton Coin Co…

Used

5 Cents-Buffalo Nickel-USA-Choic…

1937 Original Full Horn Buffalo Nick…

Marbles Identification And …

$13.49

Thriftbooks.com

Guild D-320 Acoustic Guitar - …

1920-1937 Buffalo Nickel Set With F…

1937 Buffalo Nickel In Deluxe Holder …

$110.00

Littleton Coin Co…

Used

1920-1937 Buffalo Nickel Set With F…

$126.00

Littleton Coin Co…

Nickel Hunters : Buffalo - Monticell…

$26.98

Amazon.com

Used

1936 S Original Full Horn Buffalo Nick…

Five Cent Piece - Buffalo - 1938-D …

$83.95

Littleton Coin Co…

Used

Rare Indian Head / Buffalo U.S. 5 Ce…

$1,272.00

eBay

Free shipping

24Kt Gold-Highlighted Buffal…

$9.95

Danbury Mint

Used

Rare Indian Head Buffalo U S 5 Cen…

$200.00

eBay

Used

Five Cent Piece - Buffalo - 1938-D …

$83.95

Littleton Coin Co…

Used

1934 Buffalo Nickel AU50 | About Unc…

$83.95

Littleton Coin Co…

Used

1937-D Buffalo Nickel, 3-Legged …

$3,040.00

Littleton Coin Co…

Used

1937 Buffalo Nickel (NGC MS65) | Ge…

$124.00

Littleton Coin Co…

Used

1936 S Original Full Horn Buffalo Nick…

1926 Buffalo Nickel | About Uncirculat…

$75.50

Littleton Coin Co…

Used

Rare Indian Head / Buffalo U.S. 5 Ce…

$1,272.00

eBay

Free shipping

24Kt Gold-Highlighted Buffal…

$9.95

Danbury Mint

Used

Rare Indian Head Buffalo U S 5 Cen…

$200.00

eBay

Used

2009 P&D Lincoln Penny Anniversar…

$12.50

Littleton Coin Co…

Used

1938-D Buffalo Nickel & Trans-Mi…

$155.00

Littleton Coin Co…

Used

1942-1945 Jefferson Wartim…

$135.00

Littleton Coin Co…

Used

Five Cent Piece - Buffalo - 1935 VF …

$10.75

Littleton Coin Co…

The 2026 Blue Book: Handbook …

1934 Buffalo Nickel AU2 | About Uncir…

$76.00

Littleton Coin Co…

Showing 1 - 36 out of 178 results for "buffalo nickel price guide"
Sort by:
Featured
Featured
Price - High To Low
Price - Low To High
1. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  Buffalo Nickels Collection
  $35.90
  D
  Danbury Mint
2. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  Buffalo Nickels W/ Various Dates A…
  $1.29
  E
  eBay
3. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  The Last Buffalo Nickels - P, D, & S …
  $99.95
  C
  Collectors Alliance
4. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  5
  ·
  1
  BUFFALO NICKELS- 3 DIFFEREN…
  $10.20
  A
  Amazon.com
5. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  Buffalo Nickels No Dates
  $600.00
  U
  US eBay
  Free shipping
6. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  Buffalo Nickels No Date Error Coin
  $750.00
  U
  US eBay
  Free shipping
7. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  Buffalo Nickels Lot 47 Two Error Nic…
  $250.00
  U
  US eBay
  Free shipping
8. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  Buffalo Nickels Roll Lot Of 40 Full D…
  $49.99
  E
  eBay.com
9. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  Used
  4.8
  ·
  41
  4.8
  41 ratings
  Lot Of 5 Buffalo Nickels, Indian Hea…
  $3.99
  E
  Etsy
10. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  USA Liberty V Nickels Coin - Full D…
  $22.39
  A
  Amazon.com
  Free shipping
11. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  Buffalo Nickels Set Of 4 Coins Vario…
  $10.00
  U
  US eBay
  Free shipping
12. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  Full Date Buffalo Nickels Us Coins …
  $92.10
  E
  Everymarket INC
13. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  Buffalo Nickels
  $18.95
  A
  Amazon.com
14. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  5
  ·
  1
  $1 Face 35% Silver War Nickels (1.…
  $63.64
  M
  Money Metals Exchange
15. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  Buffalo Nickels No Dates. Buffalo 19…
  $600.00
  E
  eBay.com
  Free shipping
16. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  SALE
  5
  ·
  10
  5
  10 ratings
  Buffalo Nickels - Dated 1913-1938
  $0.47
  $0.49
  E
  Etsy
17. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  Used
  Buffalo Nickels No Date / Low Grad…
  $42.99
  E
  Etsy
  Free shipping
18. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  Used
  Whitman Red Book Series 8: A Gui…
  $9.83
  B
  BooksRun
19. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  5
  ·
  33
  5
  33 ratings
  Random Silver Eagles (Dates/Type …
  $55.95
  M
  Money Metals Exchange
20. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  Buffalo Nickel No Date Or Mint
  $400.00
  U
  US eBay
  Free shipping
21. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  Last Decade Of Buffalo Nickels
  $49.95
  C
  Collectors Alliance
22. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  Used
  Buffalo (Indian Head) Nickels Lot O…
  $30.00
  E
  Etsy
  Free shipping
23. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  SALE
  Buffalo Silver Round Fine Silver 1 O…
  $63.50
  $127.00
  W
  warehousesoverstock
  Free shipping
24. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  Lot Of 100 Buffalo Nickels Mostly Le…
  $60.00
  E
  eBay.com
  Free shipping
25. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  Used
  4.7
  ·
  3
  4.7
  3 ratings
  Buffalo Nickels With Dates 9 Per Lo…
  $15.89
  Etsy
26. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  1 Oz American Eagle Design Round
  $64.07
  B
  Bullion.com
27. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  4.7
  ·
  9
  4.7
  9 ratings
  2025 1 Oz American Buffalo BU Coi…
  $4,800.20
  B
  Bullion.com
28. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  Buffalo Nickels 1913 To 1938 Circul…
  $7.30
  A
  Amazon.com
29. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  First And Last Buffalo Nickels
  $59.95
  T
  The Patriotic Mint
30. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  40 Indian Head/Buffalo Nickels Full …
  $39.99
  E
  eBay.com
  Free shipping
31. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  Buffalo Nickel Full 4-Digit Date 40-C…
  $37.60
  E
  eBay.com
  Free shipping
32. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  Buffalo Nickel, No Date, No Mint
  $15.00
  U
  US eBay
  Free shipping
33. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  Buffalo Nickel, Rare Proof, No Date …
  $550.00
  U
  US eBay
  Free shipping
34. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  4.6
  ·
  34
  4.6
  34 ratings
  1 Oz American Buffalo BU Coin - R…
  $4,789.78
  B
  Bullion.com
35. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  1936 Buffalo Nickel Good+
  $8.32
  W
  Walmart
  Free shipping
36. Saved
  Save to wishlist
  Buffalo Nickel Partially Filled Collect…
  $64.00
  E
  eBay.com
Oops! We are sorry, something went wrong.
Continue your shopping by clicking on another product
Product added to your wishlist! View wishlist
Sign in to see your saved products on any device
Product removed from your wishlist! View wishlist
Sign in to see your saved products on any device
Something went wrong. Please try again later.
Product is added to compare already. Please refresh the page.
Product is not found in compare. Please refresh the page.
5 Products already added. Please delete existing selection to add this.
Sponsored
✕
Learn how your ads are chosen
littletoncoin.com
Why you're seeing this ad?
Your current search
Advertiser Details
Name: Littleton Coin Company
Location: United States
Verified by Microsoft Advertising. See more ads from this advertiser on Bing. Learn more about the Microsoft Advertiser Identity Verification Program.
amazon.com
Why you're seeing this ad?
Your current search
Advertiser Details
Name: Amazon.com Services, Inc
Location: United States
Verified by Microsoft Advertising. See more ads from this advertiser on Bing. Learn more about the Microsoft Advertiser Identity Verification Program.
ebay.com
Why you're seeing this ad?
Your current search
Advertiser Details
Name: Harold Scott Waldron
Location: United States
Verified by Microsoft Advertising. See more ads from this advertiser on Bing. Learn more about the Microsoft Advertiser Identity Verification Program.
moneymetals.com
Why you're seeing this ad?
Your current search
The gender you selected in your Microsoft account and your search history
The birthdate you shared in your Microsoft account and your search history
Advertiser Details
Name: Money Metals Exchange
Location: United States
Verified by Microsoft Advertising. See more ads from this advertiser on Bing. Learn more about the Microsoft Advertiser Identity Verification Program.
walmart.com
Why you're seeing this ad?
Your current search
Advertiser Details
Name: Wal-Mart Dotcom GNFR
Location: United States
Verified by Microsoft Advertising. See more ads from this advertiser on Bing. Learn more about the Microsoft Advertiser Identity Verification Program.
yamaguo.com
Why you're seeing this ad?
Your current search
Advertiser Details
Name: Inmobi Pte Ltd
Location: Singapore
Verified by Microsoft Advertising. See more ads from this advertiser on Bing. Learn more about the Microsoft Advertiser Identity Verification Program.
thriftbooks.com
Why you're seeing this ad?
Your current search
Advertiser Details
Name: Thrift Books LLC
Location: United States
Verified by Microsoft Advertising. See more ads from this advertiser on Bing. Learn more about the Microsoft Advertiser Identity Verification Program.
etsy.com
Why you're seeing this ad?
Your current search
Advertiser Details
Name: Pricegrabber.com
Location: United States
Verified by Microsoft Advertising. See more ads from this advertiser on Bing. Learn more about the Microsoft Advertiser Identity Verification Program.
Ad settings
Used
1906 Liberty Head Nickel AU50 | Abo…
$130.00
Littleton Coin Co…
Red Book Series 9: A Guide Book Of …
$20.98

$24.95
Amazon.com
5.0
·
21
1 Troy Oz. Buffalo Authentic Silver R…
$74.99
Amazon.com
4.5
·
5
Used
Rare Buffalo Nickel
$500.00
eBay
Used
1923 Buffalo Nickel
$799.00
Littleton Coin Co…
Used
1935 Buffalo Nickel | Gem Uncirculate…
$195.00
Littleton Coin Co…
The 2026 Red Book: A Guide Bo…
$16.73

$17.95
Amazon.com
4.5
·
946
Lionel Trains Pocket Price Guide 1901 …
$22.99
Amazon.com
5.0
·
4
1-1/4 Ounce RCM 2021 Bison Buffal…
$70.09
Money Metals Ex…
5.0
·
1
1930 Buffalo Nickel BU
$124.99
Walmart
Free shipping
American Bison Or Buffalo, J. Audubon
$70.00

$140.00
Yamaguo
Free shipping
The Bluebook: A Uniform System …
$54.01

$61.25
Amazon.com
4.0
·
4
Standard Catalog Of Farm Toys: Identif…
$35.49
Thriftbooks.com
Free shipping
Used
1938-D Buffalo Nickel, D Over S …
$350.00
Littleton Coin Co…
Authentic Buffalo Nickel
$70.00
Etsy
5.0
·
1K+
Used
1938-D Buffalo Nickel | Gem Unci…
$155.00
Littleton Coin Co…
Millers Antiques Handbook & Pric…
$39.29

$49.99
Amazon.com
4.5
·
46
Authentic 1936 Buffalo Indian Nic…
$39.90
Amazon.com
5.0
·
5
1 Troy Oz. Incuse Indian Authentic S…
$79.99
Amazon.com
4.0
·
7
Copper Buffalo Round - 1 AVDP …
$1.65
Money Metals Ex…
5.0
·
11
- Buffalo Nickel Coin Value | Ask an Online Coin Appraiser
  https://www.askantiqueexperts.com › ask-appraisers › online-24-7-365
  SponsoredFast and Convenient Coin Appraisals. Ask an Appraiser Anything Online. Get Professional Help Online. Trusted, Certified Experts Answer You in Minutes.
  Site visitors: Over 10K in the past month
  No High Fees · Unlimited Conversations · 24/7 Support · Family Membership
- Buffalo Nickels | Buffalo Nickels For Sale
  https://www.goldeneaglecoin.com
  Free Shipping
  Sponsored100% Money-Back Guarantee. Low Prices. Buy Online Or Call Today! Buy Gold and Silver Bullion online securely with Golden Eagle Coins
  BBB Accredited Business · Safe, Secure Delivery · Sign Up Online · Free Shipping All Orders
  Types: Silver Coins, Silver Bars, 90% Silver Coin Bags, Silver Eagle Coins
  4.5/5 (34K reviews)
  - Buy Silver ·
  - 90 percent silver coins ·
  - Buy Palladium ·
  - One Ounce Silver Bars
- 1
- 2
- 3
- 4
- 5

Brand

Price

Material

Seller

Shop Buffalo Nickel Price Guide

Buffalo Nickel Coin Value | Ask an Online Coin Appraiser

Buffalo Nickels | Buffalo Nickels For Sale